UK : Egg/Citigroup Clamps Down On Riskier Credit Card Customers

Probably no coincidence that Citigroup is forced to make the move first and one of the largest US pawnbroker & payday lender is entering the market at the same time..... Once again their risk modeling wasn´t quite perferct...... How can you buy a UK credit card company close to a top in the UK housing market...... But i think it is very safe to say that others will have to follow ( not only in the UK ) Citi in this kind of tightening.....I suggest to read this Total UK personal debt statistic February 2008 from Credit Action to understand the magnitude of the mess especially in UK .

Sicher kein Zufall das ausgerechnet Citigroup den ersten Schritt machen muß und gleichzeitig das größte US Pfandleihaus & einer der größen "Kredithaie" in den UK Markt eintritt..... Es sieht so aus als wenn die mal wieder genau zum Top eine riskante Investition getätigt hätten.... In diesem Fall bin ich mir sicher das Citi mit diesem Schritt nicht lange alleine bleiben wird. Andere Anbieter ( auch länderübergreifend ) werden sich dieser Art der Kreditverknappung anschließen müssen.... Um einen Überblick über das Ausmaß gerade in UK zu bekommen empfehle ich einen Blick auf diese Übersicht Total UK personal debt statistic February 2008 von Credit Action zu werfen.

This quote sume it up / Dieses Zitat spricht Bände

"We can certainly understand the concerns, but even if people are up-to-date with repayments, they are people we decided we no longer wish to lend money to regardless of their status." Egg spokesman

Egg customer anger at credit move BBC
Angry customers of internet bank Egg have hit out at its decision to cancel their credit cards.

Egg says 161,000 cards belonging to people whose credit profiles have deteriorated since they signed up will stop working in 35 days' time.

But people who insist they have good records have been contacting the BBC to say they are on the list.

A spokesman for the bank said those affected were customers it no longer wanted to lend to "regardless of their current status".

Credit cards are being withdrawn from 7% of Egg's customers who it deems to pose an unacceptably "high risk".

This could include those who have missed repayments or exceeded their credit limit.

'Arbitrary action'
Cardholders will be able to continue making minimum monthly repayments on their balances but will not be able to spend any more after the deadline.

The move follows a "one-off" review after Egg was bought by US-based Citigroup for £575m last year.

The bank is not demanding immediate repayment of balances or making any changes to customers' terms and conditions or their interest rates. ....

Gillian Cox, of Farnham, Surrey, said she was "absolutely furious" to learn her credit card had been cancelled in what she described as an "unbelievable arbitrary action".

Mrs Cox said she and her husband are "retired, no mortgage, no debts" and "always paid the balance off in full each month".

She added that she had contacted credit reference agency Experian who said she was marked as having an excellent credit rating, "thus totally negating Egg's claim that this measure is about credit risk".

'Stop spending'
A spokesman for Egg said: "We are sorry some customers are upset after receiving notification we are ending their credit card arrangement, but they are people we do not feel it is appropriate to lend any money to."

He added: "The decision was taken after an extensive one-off review of our credit card book following acquisition by Citigroup."

Der Spiegel London - Die Internetbank Egg greift durch. Die britische Citigroup -Tochter will rund sieben Prozent ihrer zwei Millionen Kunden die Kreditkarte sperren. Offenbar haben es Egg und Mutterkonzern Citi mit der Angst zu tun bekommen - sie fürchten, die Risikokunden könnten sich übernehmen und ihre Darlehen nicht zurückzahlen können. Offiziell heißt es: Das Kreditrisiko der "riskanten" Kunden sei zu hoch.

Egg teilte zwar mit, der Schritt habe nichts mit der weltweiten Kreditkrise zu tun. Es handele sich bloß um eine "Neubewertung der Risiken", nachdem Egg im vergangenen Jahr von der Citigroup gekauft worden war. Die Maßnahme zeigt aber, dass Banken weltweit konservativer bei der Darlehensvergabe werden und hart gegen Risikokunden durchgreifen.

Die Egg-Mutter Citi hatte sich bei riskanten Kreditgeschäften so sehr verhoben, dass an den Finanzmärkten sogar zeitweise Insolvenzgerüchte zirkulierten. Citi hat im Zuge der Kreditkrise mehr als 18 Milliarden Dollar abschreiben müssen und damit einen Verlust im vierten Quartal von rund zehn Milliarden Dollar verbucht. Mit der Wahrheit über das Ausmaß der Krise rückte Citi nur scheibchenweise heraus. Egg will die Karten innerhalb von 35 Tagen sperren, die Kunden wurden bereits angeschrieben.

The Rise of Pawn Shops and Fringe Banking

This is probably one of the very few sectors in the US financial system with a very bright future.....Hat tip to Minyanville for digging this from the FT

Das Geschäft der Pfandleihhäuser dürfte eines der wenigen Sektoren im US Finanzsystem mit glänzenden Zukunftsperspektiven sein.... Dank geht an Minyanville für das ausgraben dieser Geschichte der FT.

US pawnbrokers benefit from hard times FT
Hard times in the US are benefiting pawnbrokers as beleaguered consumers pledge jewels, electronics and other goods in return for loans with interest rates running as high as 300 per cent a year.

Dave Adelman, president of the National Pawnbrokers Association, said the number of loans at US pawn shops had risen 15-20 per cent since October. He attributed the increase to rising fuel prices and deteriorating economic conditions – an assessment echoed by other industry executives.

“Brief and shallow downturns in the economy may benefit our business model,” said Daniel Feehan, chief executive of Cash America, the biggest US pawnbroker chain, with 942 locations. ( Cash America Presentation )

> Probably no coincident that they have entered the UK market in mid 2007....

> Sicher kein Zufall das die Mitte 2007 in den UK Markt eingetreten sind......

Pawnbrokers offer loans in return for personal items. Customers can buy back their property for the value of the loan plus a fee, which works out to an interest rate that can reach 300 per cent on an annualised basis, according to the NPA. If borrowers do not pay off the loan in a given time, the unredeemed item can be sold.

> Here comes the definition from "Cash Advance " & "Pawn" via Cash America

> Hier die Definition der Begriffe vie Cash America

Cash America said on Thursday its profits had risen 21 per cent to $26.3m in the fourth quarter, reflecting higher sales of pawned goods and more loans.

Alan Fishbein of the Consumer Federation of America said pawnbrokers and other “fringe” banking operations – such as those making loans against future pay cheques or car titles – had grown as banks had withdrawn from poorer areas. About $48bn in payday loans are made every year and the revenues in the whole fringe banking industry are an estimated $12bn-$15bn, according to Dennis Telzrow, a consumer finance analyst at Stephens, an investment bank.

An estimated 10m US households are thought to be outside the banking system, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. The NPA estimates there are 12,000 to 14,000 pawnbroker shops in the US.

On Manhattan’s 47th Street, the New York block through which about 90 per cent of US diamonds are sourced, some merchants report a sharp uptick in the amount of jewellery being brought in for sale.

“Its real sad – they don’t want to sell,” said Ruben, a 52-year-old street hawker who buys jewellery from passers-by in the diamond district.

“They might have paid $150,000 for a necklace but they will get back $25,000 or $30,000 at most. But it’s either that or lose their house.”

Credit Excess / Baltics

Wow! We have a clear winner in the category "easy credit". beforeThe the following charts and data are just breathtaking. .....The credit explosion explains why the Baltic Real Estate market is so "frothy".

Anschnallen! Wir haben den eindeutigen Gewinner in Sachen "Easy Credit" gefunden. . Die nachfolgenden Charts und Daten verschlagen einen aber wirklich den Atem....... Das erklärt natürlich auch diesen Bericht über den baltischen Immobilienmarkt.


Banking Risks Rise in Eastern Europe
Credit to the private sector has expanded at a fast clip in central and eastern Europe during the past decade, outpacing most other regions of the world.

Rapid credit growth (see Chart 1) reflects a number of factors:

• low levels of financial development and pent-up demand pressures following decades of socialist economic management;

• good macroeconomic discipline and membership in the European Union (EU), which lowered country risk premiums; and

• improved access to foreign capital following the entry of foreign banks and the opening of capital accounts.

Assessing the risks
Rapid credit growth has brought important benefits, helping channel domestic and foreign savings to households and investors and supporting financial sector development and economic growth in the region. But the brisk expansion of credit is raising concerns about macroeconomic and prudential risks (that is to say, whether banks remain sound).

Quantifying these risks is a challenge because countries in central and eastern Europe have not gone through a full credit cycle yet, and financial soundness indicators tend to improve in the upward phase of the credit cycle.

But experience in industrial and emerging market countries suggests that credit booms can be associated with unsustainable domestic demand booms, overheating, and asset price bubbles. Financial sector difficulties also cannot be ruled out—for example, loan losses may occur during a deep recession or following a large exchange rate depreciation if loans are denominated in foreign currency.

> from Baltic blues / Economist

How significant these risks are in central and eastern Europe and what role public policy should play in containing them are key questions facing policymakers.

Banking risks on the rise
On the surface, rapid credit growth in central and eastern Europe does not appear to have weakened banks. (It remains to be seen how the current turmoil in financial markets will affect banks in the region, but so far there have been no signs of a major fallout.) However, the reason financial soundness indicators are not yet pointing to a deterioration in credit quality could be that they are based on systemwide statistics rather than reflecting assessments of data from individual banks and there is a lag before bank data become publicly available.

Our analysis suggests that the granting of credit is becoming increasingly divorced from bank soundness—all banks, including weak ones, seem to be expanding at an equally rapid pace. This suggests that prudential risks are on the rise.

Our findings underscore the importance of forward-looking and risk-based supervision to keep the risks associated with rapid credit growth at manageable levels while maximizing the benefits of credit for financial development and economic growth.

In particular, supervisors need to give more attention to weaker banks that are growing rapidly. This would also be consistent with the risk-based approach to supervision that central and eastern European countries are moving to as they implement the new capital adequacy accord, known as Basel II.

Increased prudential risks are most apparent in the fastest-growing credit markets. These markets include lending to households, foreign currency-denominated or indexed lending, and lending in the three Baltic countries, where weaker banks are expanding at a faster rate than sounder banks (see Chart 2). A stronger policy response is thus warranted in each of these markets. Such a response may involve, for example, higher capital requirements and tighter loan classification and provisioning rules, differentiated on a bank-by-bank basis

But experience in industrial and emerging market countries suggests that credit booms can be associated with unsustainable domestic demand booms, overheating, and asset price bubbles. Financial sector difficulties also cannot be ruled out—for example, loan losses may occur during a deep recession or following a large exchange rate depreciation if loans are denominated in foreign currency.

How significant these risks are in central and eastern Europe and what role public policy should play in containing them are key questions facing policymakers.

Banking risks on the rise
Our analysis suggests that the granting of credit is becoming increasingly divorced from bank soundness—all banks, including weak ones, seem to be expanding at an equally rapid pace. This suggests that prudential risks are on the rise.

Increased prudential risks are most apparent in the fastest-growing credit markets. These markets include lending to households, foreign currency-denominated or indexed lending, and lending in the three Baltic countries, where weaker banks are expanding at a faster rate than sounder banks (see Chart 2). A stronger policy response is thus warranted in each of these markets. Such a response may involve, for example, higher capital requirements and tighter loan classification and provisioning rules, differentiated on a bank-by-bank basis